A “one-size-fits-all” strategy doesn’t work. Instead, leaders will need to balance how much direction and encouragement they provide. The Situational Leadership Model that Paul Hersey, PhD, and Kenneth Blanchard, PhD, created and introduced in their 1969 landmark book Management of Organizational Behavior, was developed for just this purpose. The model, originally called the “Life Cycle Theory of Leadership,” was later renamed “Situational Leadership.”
The Situational Leadership Model’s fundamental principle is that there is no single “best” leadership style. Successful leaders are people who adapt their leadership styles to the performance readiness level of the person or team they are trying to lead and influence. Effective leadership varies based not only on the person or team but also on the task, job, or function that needs accomplishing. The model breaks leadership into four primary styles, mapped directly to employee development levels:
- Style 4—Delegating, empowering, or monitoring: Team member is trusted to make task-related decisions, identify best practices, and suggest improvements
- Style 3—Participating, collaborating, or facilitating: Team member makes decisions with support from the leader to enhance mastery
- Style 2—Selling, coaching, or explaining: Leader still makes decisions but provides context and engages in dialog to reinforce buy-in
- Style 1—Telling, directing, or guiding: Leader makes decisions and closely supervises execution with the goal of creating movement
Successful leaders are people who adapt their leadership styles to the performance readiness level of the person or team they are trying to lead and influence
After the leader’s diagnosis, the appropriate style and necessary amounts of relationship behavior and task behavior are applied and communicated to the team member to support their needs and advance development. This model has several core strengths and benefits:
- It is a multidirectional model that can be leveraged for influencing up, down, and across the organization
- It creates a common language of performance
- The model accelerates the pace and quality of employee development
- It is a repeatable process that your leaders can leverage to effectively influence other people’s behavior
- The model uses task specificity as a mechanism to let leaders maximize their influence-related impact
- It addresses situations in which people are developing or regressing
Situational leadership can be a potent tool in the leadership’s toolbox. However, even when leveraged by an experienced and skilled leader, it is not a magic formula that can be universally applied. Sometimes, it can be time consuming and complex to carry off and there are circumstances in which it may not be the best strategy, such as when a team lacks substantial capability; when the teams lacks drive or desire; and when the team environment is toxic, fraught with big egos.
The model has been around for many years, but it is as relevant today as it was when it was introduced. Many organizations have leveraged it broadly with great success.